What Criminal Charges Can You Face After a Fatal Car Accident in Arizona?

What Criminal Charges Can You Face After a Fatal Car Accident in Arizona?

A fatal car accident can lead to serious criminal charges in Arizona, even if the driver did not mean to hurt anyone. Depending on what happened, prosecutors may consider charges such as negligent homicide, manslaughter, second-degree murder, or leaving the scene of an accident. However, a person’s death does not automatically mean the driver committed a crime. Investigators must look at what happened, whether the driver’s actions caused the accident, and whether the evidence supports the charge.

Attorney Chad Pajerski has practiced law in Arizona since 1999 and has been a Board-Certified Criminal Law Specialist since 2010. This designation is held by a select group of Arizona attorneys who meet strict requirements involving criminal defense experience, felony jury trials, professional review, and legal knowledge. If you are under investigation or facing charges after a fatal accident, schedule a free consultation with Pajerski Law to discuss your situation directly with Chad and learn about your legal options.

Negligent Homicide Charges After a Fatal Accident

In Arizona, negligent homicide may be charged when a person causes someone else’s death through criminal negligence. This means the driver failed to recognize a serious risk that a reasonable person would have noticed. The conduct must involve more than an ordinary mistake or a brief lapse in judgment.

After a fatal accident, prosecutors may look at whether the driver:

  • Was seriously distracted behind the wheel.
  • Failed to notice an obvious and significant danger.
  • Drove in a way that created a substantial risk to others.
  • Ignored conditions that made the road unsafe.

Negligent homicide is a Class 4 felony, but the possible penalties depend on the facts of the case and the driver’s criminal history. A charge does not mean the prosecution can prove the driver acted with criminal negligence or caused the accident. Other factors, such as road conditions, vehicle problems, or another driver’s actions, may also have contributed to the crash.

Chad Pajerski can review the evidence, examine how the accident happened, and determine whether the facts support the charge.

Manslaughter Charges Following a Fatal Collision

A driver may face manslaughter charges in Arizona if prosecutors believe the driver recklessly caused someone else’s death. Unlike criminal negligence, which involves failing to recognize a serious risk, reckless conduct involves recognizing the risk and choosing to ignore it.

Prosecutors may investigate whether the driver was:

  • Driving at an extremely high speed.
  • Taking part in a street race.
  • Ignoring traffic signals or other obvious dangers.
  • Driving while impaired by alcohol or drugs.

Manslaughter is a Class 2 felony, and the possible penalties depend on the circumstances and the driver’s criminal history. Chad Pajerski can review the evidence and examine whether the facts support the charge.

When Can a Fatal Accident Lead to Second-Degree Murder Charges?

Second-degree murder charges may arise when a driver’s actions create a grave risk of death and show extreme indifference to human life. These cases generally involve conduct that prosecutors believe goes beyond the recklessness associated with manslaughter.

Examples may include:

  • Driving at an exceptionally high speed through a crowded area.
  • Engaging in highly dangerous behavior despite clear warnings.
  • Driving while severely impaired and ignoring obvious risks.

Second-degree murder is a Class 1 felony in Arizona. However, a fatal accident or impaired driving does not automatically justify this charge. Chad Pajerski can review the circumstances and challenge whether the evidence supports the prosecution’s claims.

What Happens if a Driver Leaves the Scene of a Fatal Accident?

Arizona law requires drivers involved in an accident that causes injury or death to stop, remain at the scene, and provide required information or assistance. Leaving before meeting these obligations may result in a separate felony charge.

The severity of the charge depends on the circumstances:

  • A driver who leaves the scene of a fatal accident may face a Class 3 felony.
  • If the driver caused the accident and then left the scene, the charge may be a Class 2 felony.

These charges can apply even when the driver did not intend to cause the accident. Chad Pajerski can examine what happened and determine whether the evidence supports the allegations.

Why Board Certification Matters in a Fatal Accident Case

Fatal accident cases often involve serious felony charges, conflicting evidence, and questions about what caused the crash. The attorney you choose should understand how to evaluate those issues and prepare a defense.

Chad Pajerski is a Board-Certified Criminal Law Specialist, a designation held by a select group of attorneys in Arizona. To earn this certification, an attorney must meet requirements involving:

  • Significant experience practicing criminal law.
  • Participation in felony jury trials, including serious felony cases.
  • Review by other legal professionals.
  • Specialized legal education and demonstrated legal knowledge.
  • High professional and ethical standards.

Chad has held this certification since 2010. His experience with jury trials and complex evidence can be valuable when prosecutors claim a driver acted negligently, recklessly, or with extreme disregard for human life.

When you work with Pajerski Law, Chad handles your case personally. You are not passed to an associate attorney or left wondering who is responsible for your defense.

What Should You Do if You Are Under Investigation?

A fatal accident investigation can begin immediately, and what you say or do afterward may affect your case. Even if you believe the crash was not your fault, it is important to take the situation seriously and understand your rights.

  1. Remain at the scene: Follow applicable legal requirements and provide any information or assistance required by law.
  2. Seek medical attention: Get help if you or anyone else involved in the accident needs medical care.
  3. Be careful when speaking: Avoid discussing the accident in detail before consulting an attorney.
  4. Stay off social media: Do not post about the crash or share details online.
  5. Preserve important information: Keep documents, photographs, and other records related to the accident.
  6. Contact a criminal defense attorney: Speak with an attorney as soon as possible to understand your rights and legal options.

Early legal guidance can help you avoid statements that may be misunderstood and protect evidence that could support your defense.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Face Criminal Charges if I Did Not Intend to Cause the Accident?

Yes. Negligent homicide and manslaughter charges do not require proof that you intended to cause someone’s death. Prosecutors must show that your actions met the legal requirements for the specific charge.

What Is the Difference Between Negligent Homicide and Manslaughter?

Negligent homicide generally involves failing to recognize a serious risk. Manslaughter involves recognizing the risk and choosing to ignore it. The difference can affect the severity of the charge and potential penalties.

Can I Be Charged if Another Driver Contributed to the Accident?

Possibly. Investigators may examine the actions of everyone involved and determine whether your conduct contributed to the crash. Another driver’s behavior may also provide important evidence for your defense.

Does a Fatal Accident Automatically Mean I Will Go to Prison?

No. The possible outcome depends on the charges, available evidence, your criminal history, and the circumstances of the accident. A criminal defense attorney can explain the potential consequences in your situation.

Should I Speak With Police Before Contacting an Attorney?

You may need to provide certain information after an accident, but you can seek legal advice before answering detailed questions. An attorney can help you understand your rights and avoid statements that may be misinterpreted.

Speak With a Board-Certified Criminal Law Specialist

A fatal car accident can raise serious questions about what happened, who was responsible, and whether criminal charges are justified. The outcome may depend on the evidence, the circumstances of the crash, and how effectively your attorney challenges the allegations.

Attorney Chad Pajerski is a Board-Certified Criminal Law Specialist who personally represents clients facing serious criminal charges. He can review your situation, explain your legal options, and help you understand what to expect.

Schedule a free consultation with Pajerski Law to discuss your situation directly with Attorney Chad Pajerski and take the next step to protect your rights.

Frequently Asked Questions
Open FAQ
Open FAQ
Open FAQ
Open FAQ
Open FAQ
Open FAQ
Need Help?
Free Consultation:
Hours
Mon-Fri: 9am to 6pm
Sat-Sun: 9am to 5pm
Office
645 N 4th Ave Suite B1, Phoenix, AZ 85003
lEGAL dISCLAIMER

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. Pajerski Law's legal team is licensed to practice law in Arizona. We invite you to contact us, but please be aware that contacting us does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until an attorney-client relationship has been established.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Pajerski Law AddressPajerski Law Address
Case Types:
Free Consultation
Copyright © 2026 Pajerski Law. All Rights Reserved.
Designed by:
Lab Coat Marketing
Lab Coat Marketing